Sunday, March 10, 2013

Literature Review Blog # 3

Race and Class Matters at an Elite College ( Book by 
Elizabeth Aries)









In this book Aries interviews students from different classes and social backgrounds, over a period of four years. She interviews them thrice, since their freshman year in college. The authors explains in this book that many students come from segregated communities, and have concepts of stereotypes, and these concepts come into play when they enter college and get a platform to interact with others.
She says that colleges can play a vital role in changing student's concepts about stereotypes. She provides a rare glimpse into the challenges faced by black and white college students. Aries chronicles what students learned from racial and class diversity-and what colleges might do to help their students learn more. Aries quotes sociologist Karabel, who states that ". . . the powers in higher education became to recognize that . . . taking strong measures to rectify racial injustice was not simply a moral imperative; it was also a matter of enlightened self-interest at a time when the existing order was under challenge"(chapter 1 page 2). here she talks about how universities were focused to increase diversity at their campuses for self-interest. She also states " The vastly increased diversity in race and class in the student body not only afforded opportunities for social mobility to underrepresented minorities and students with less financial means;it also had potential to increase student's understanding to those different to themselves and to challenge previous notions about race and class" (chapter 1 page 2). It means that when students from different backgrounds were admitted to colleges,they could be around people belonging from different races and form their  perceptions about this interactive experience . She also quotes Harvard social psychologist, who in his book,  " Prejudice (unless deeply rooted in the character structure of the individual) may be reduced by equal status contact between majority and minority groups in pursuit of common goals"chapter 1 page5). This also refers to as a solution to mend the gap between racism at college. Furthermore, Aries also states that " The social science literature suggests that people in an in-group (e.g., the majority) tend to see members of an out-group (e.g, the minority) as homogeneous and lacking in variability, while themselves as more heterogeneous. This sets stage for stereotyping"(chapter 1 page 5). I think it's an important quote for my research as it gives a reason for the concept of racism and stereotypes. People tend to have different thoughts for one's who are similar to them, than those who have a different race and class. So, we can say that "in group" and "out group" differences can be the cause of racism and stereotypes. This book is relevant to my research as it does not only provides theoretical concept or racism, stereotypes, it's effects and solutions, in fact it is written and based on the field experience online questionnaires and face-to-face interviews.

 Elizabeth, Aries. "Race and Class Matters at an Elite College." N.p., n.d. Web. 11 Mar. 2013.
(It's a book so I am attaching a link for it's e book  version on google)





Literature Review Blog#2


Speaking of Race and Class: The Student Experience at an Elite College
(Book)
 This book is written by Elizabeth Aries and Richard Berman. In this book Aries Interviews 58 undergraduates  from class of 2009 at Amherst University. She interviewed the students since they were freshman and completed this study in four years. In the interviews the students express their experience and thinking about the role of racism and class-difference in college. She presents the student's personal perceptions of their experiences. The coauthor Richard Burmen extends the concept of racism by exploring the concepts of "Stereotypes", "Inter-racial dating" and the effects of racism and class on a student's social life.Moreover, the authors look at race and class as two independent variables rather than one concept. So, the authors use the concept of intersecting race and class to examine the experiences of poor whites to that of wealthy blacks. It gives a challenge to the universities to handle and manage formal and informal learning. Elizabeth Aries is a professor of psychology at Amherst University and she has a PhD from Harvard. The co-author Richard Burmen is an independent scholar and singer/songwriter. Hence, they collaborated to work on the role of race and class in colleges. Aries quotes Harvard University President, who states " In our world today, it is not enough for us and our students to acknowledge, in an abstract sense, that other kinds of people, with other modes of thought and feeling and action, exist somewhere. . ." (Chapter 1, page 2). This quote illustrates one of the importance or benefit of diversity at a campus, which is that students from different backgrounds get to interact with each other and change their perceptions about others . The author further quotes Emily a student, who states, " I kind of feel like i have been dropped on Mars. . . I mean, it's so different" ( Chapter 1,page 1).  It describes the feelings of students when they experience different races at their college campuses.The Harvard University President also says ". . . No formal academic study can replace continued association with others who are different from ourselves,and who challenge our preconceptions,prejudices,and assumptions, even as we challenge theirs." (chapter 1,page 2). This means that students can't change their perceptions about stereotypes and racism by studying , rather they need to experience it in their actual life. I think this book is also good for my topic as it describes the role of race and race talk at college.

Elizabeth, Aries, and Burmen Richard. "Speaking of Race and Class: The Student Experience at an Elite College [e book]." N.p., n.d. Web. 11 Mar. 2013
(still have to get the e book version but i'm putting up a link to it's review)

Friday, March 1, 2013

The Role of racism on student's academic performance Blog #1


My research would focus on the role of racism on college student's academic performance. It will also talk about the development of the concept of stereotypes in colleges. It will question whether racism is the major factor in determining a change in student's academic performance.I want to consider this topic, because I am interested in studying the effects of racism, especially on the intellectual and academic abilities.

Literature Blog #1


                             
            
  
This article is taken from the Guardian and is written by Andrew Anthony . Andrew Anthony is a journalist who has written for the Guardian since 1990s. He is also author of On Penalties (2000) and the Fall-Out(2007). In this article he has described Jane Elliot's Blue Eyes/Brown Eyes experiment. It talks about how within a short span of time Jane was able to turn innocent, loving kids into haters. He says it's hard to answer whether these anti-racist policies should be deployed or not. Moreover he Anthony talks about how the associated characteristics with the eye color effected the student's attitudes and their intellectual abilities. This experiment is done by Jane Elliot who is a well-know teacher ,lecturer and diversity trainer. She wanted to teach her classroom kids a lesson for their lifetime. Her experiment explains that racism plays a vital role in our academic performance. My research is about the role of racism in college, it also focuses on how racism impairs students intellectual abilities. Andrew quotes Jane Elliot,"Perception is everything", relates to the idea of stereotypes and how we attach meaning to skin colors. Jane Eliot states,"Racism is racism wherever you find it. White ignorance is the problem, and we white folks have now managed to export that problem all over the world." This supports the fact that the topic of racism is ignored and not given much attention. Even if it is given attention,nothing is done to eradicate it . Andrews question in this article is that is it possible to eradicate racism by analyzing Jane's experiment. This quote by Jane Elliot could explain one of the causes of racism in college , ""the main thing, white people are rapidly losing their numerical majority in the United States of America. And so people of colour are going to be the people in positions in power in the future. White people are finally beginning to realize that. Some of them are scared to death." So, the fear to be left behind is a reason for racism? i am also analyzing other scholarly articles on this topic. So far this is one explaining the detail of the study carried out by Jane .

Anthony, Andrew. "Jane Elliott, the American Schoolmarm Who Would Rid Us of Our Racism." The Guardian. Guardian News and Media, 17 Oct. 2009. Web. 02 Mar. 2013.
                     

Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Research Proposal


Ghania
Professor Goeller
Research in Disciplines
February 24,2013
Research Proposal


Working Title:  Racism and it’s consequences amongst college students

Topic

           My research focuses on the role of racism in colleges. It will also talk about different levels of racism faced by students with different ethnicities. The research will also mention the concept of stereotypes formed by  “ The Theory of Cognition”.  The paper will talk about the effects of racism on student’s academic performance, based on Jane Elliot’s “Blue Eyes/Brown Eyes” exercise. Moreover, it will unfold the types of “internalized racism/covert” and “ overt/obvious racism” which play a major role in big time Private schools.
Research Question
                          Can the difference in academic performance between white and colored skin students be explained by examining the theories that mention the effects of overt and covert racism amongst multiethnic students? Or is it just a matter of associating stereotypes to skin colors ?
  Theoretical Frame
                            In Jane Elliot’s experiment of “Blue Eyes/Brown Eyes”, she demonstrates that racism is interrelated to the performance of students. This experiment mentions “ Social Cognitive Theory” proposed by Neal E. Miller and John Dollard in 1941. Social cognitive theory is a learning theory based on the idea that people learn and generate their own native theories by observing what others do. This theory emphasizes a large difference between an individual’s ability to be morally competent and morally performing . Racism undermines an individual's ability to perform, by underscoring their capabilities. I am interested in inquiring how the social cognitive theory affects the academic performance of students facing racism. I am also curious to know the role and effect of university policies on the issue of racism.
     The topic of racism amongst students in today’s  multi ethnic colleges has raised a lot of brows . There are a number of books, scholarly articles and journals written about racism and it’s consequences. I am an international student, with a different ethnic background from “white” americans, so i think the topic of stereotypes being attached to skin colors and racism relates to me. Although not in college life but in personal life when I moved to US I faced racism and I can relate to it too. The concept of attaching stereotypes to skin colors also relates to me, because being a “desi”, which means Indian or Pakistani attaches a tag that “You must be good at Maths”. In my calc class last semester one of my classmates thought I was better than her in math and when I asked her the reason, she replied “ because Indians are good at math”. So , is it that all desis are good at math? Obviously not ! I was never good at math, it was just that I practiced a lot to get a B plus in my Calc class.  I know a family friend who studies in UK and was beaten up by black college students just because he was a Pakistani. I have various life experiences which can tap into my topic of racism and stereotypes. I think the concept of racism leads to the idea of stereotypes.
Research and Plan
                           As mentioned above my research will include Jane Elliot’s experiment of Blue Eyes/Brown Eyes , which reflects the idea that people’s performance is affected by their social standing.
So, If a student was told that he or she is inferior to others then it would deteriorate his/her’s performance. Whereas, if the same student was told that he/she is superior to other than it would change his/her’s attitude towards others and would also improve performance. This is the most relevant research on my topic as it demonstrates the direct effect of racism on individual student’s capabilities by the process of social cognition. I want to further scrutinize these factors. My research also emcompasses the study “Critical Race Theory, Racial Microaggressions, and Campus Racial Climate: The Experiences of African American College Students” done in University of California . This study mentions critical race theory as a framework providing an examination of racial microaggressions and how they influence the collegiate racial climate. The study on “Anger, racism, caste discrimination, and posttraumatic stress disorder in African-American and Indian college students” also talks about the negative psychological impact of racism amongst African American and Indian college students. I have also read through the article “ Invisible Racism” by Cabrera, L who uses Antonio Gramsci's theory of hegemony and Paulo Friere's conception of liberatory praxis and  examines how white male college students' racial ideologies both reinforce and challenge the existing racial paradigm. This refers to covert racism coming into effect. I am also looking at other articles such as “The Metastereotypes and the black white divide: A Qualitative View of Race on an Elite College Campus”. This article also talks about the development of the concept of stereotypes in a college campus and also about it’s consequences. Furthermore, I am also looking into the article “Racial stereotypes and gender in context”. It gives insightful and interesting relationship between stereotypes concepts and academic performance. It is greatly related to my main field of research. As states in all of the above mentioned articles, racism does play a major role in student’s academic performance and mental health, but i will explore any other limitations or exceptions to this topic.

 


                                                    Bibliography
1.Cabrera, Nolan L. "Invisible Racism: Male, Hegemonic Whiteness in Higher Education." RU Libraries. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Feb. 2013. http://search.proquest.com/docview/304855289/fulltextPDF?accountid=13626
2.Jenifer, Ericka S. "Anger, Racism, Caste Discrimination, and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder in African-American and Indian College Students." RU Libraries. N.p., n.d. Web. 25
3."Social Cognition." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 24 Feb. 2013. Web. 25 Feb. 2013.
4.Solorzano, Daniel, Miguel Ceja, and Tara Yosso. "Journal of Negro Education." JSTOR. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Feb. 2013.http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2307/2696265
5.Torres, KImberly, and Camille Z. Charles. "The Internalization of Stereotypes : Black Stereotypes about Black University of Pennsylvania Students." RU Libraries. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Feb. 2013.
6."Racial Stereotypes and Gender in Context." Sex Roles : A Journal Of Research, n.d. Web. 25 Feb. 2013. http://search.proquest.com/docview/225373602/fulltextPDF?accountid=13626

Thursday, February 21, 2013

Privatization Connection

Privatization of universities and colleges in USA has increased the autonomy of the colleges . Federal Government has little to regulate the rules governing the functioning of the colleges. There are quotas set for admitting people with different ethnicities to colleges. Sometimes even in matters of financial aid some races are more likely to get financial aid than others . For example , because of the increasing hispanic population in US , more hispanics and pushed to study and have easy access to financial aid. The article " Racism and the tuition crisis" mentions that racism is increasing in colleges . It also mentions that the rich and wealthy are more likely to dominate and control the poor . It is a fact that rich people who can afford high tuition costs ,or who give large amount of money for college donations have more influence in the running of the college than the other students. Privatization of college has diverted the attention of university administrators to money-making than on issues like racism.
Google:http://www.rougeforum.org/racismtuition.html
More articles on racism in college:http://ehis.ebscohost.com/ehost/detail?vid=3&sid=49e6c9d3-aa9d-43d0-b64b-603dc713ffbe%40sessionmgr4&hid=5&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZQ%3d%3d#db=fa3146b2&AN=76180712
This blog mentions the role of racism in college financial aid : http://collegeaffordability.blogspot.com/2006/10/financial-aid-and-race-overuse-of-r.html